2009 Men's Division III Lacrosse All-Americans
| Team | Pos. | Name of Player | College |
| 1 | A | Dailey, Jimmy | Stevenson |
| 1 | A | Kazimer, Steve | Stevenson |
| 1 | A | Thomas, Zachary | Roanoke |
| 1 | M | Berkman, Kylor | Salisbury |
| 1 | M | Morgan, Joe | Cortland |
| 1 | M | Stone, Mike | Middlebury |
| 1 | LSM | Kehoe, Tom | Gettysburg |
| 1 | SP | Santora, P.J. | St. Lawrence |
| 1 | D | Lemon, Luke | Cortland |
| 1 | D | Malangone, Terence | Wesleyan |
| 1 | D | Wiedemann, Neth | Ithaca |
| 1 | G | Cohen, Gordon | Washington College |
| 2 | A | Grugan, Casey | Cabrini |
| 2 | A | Hessler, D.J. | Tufts |
| 2 | A | Keating, Matt | Stevens |
| 2 | M | Bevacqua, Nicola | Stevenson |
| 2 | M | O’Donnell, Tom | Gettysburg |
| 2 | M | St. John, Harry | Washington & Lee |
| 2 | LSM | Simmons, Stephen | Roanoke |
| 2 | SP | Wood, David | St. John Fisher |
| 2 | D | Pabis, Jared | Western New England |
| 2 | D | Peary, Yanni | Gettysburg |
| 2 | D | Simon, Mike | Stevenson |
| 2 | G | Decker, Dave | Stevens |
| 3 | A | Follansbee, Russ | Wesleyan |
| 3 | A | Pucci, Zachary | Gettysburg |
| 3 | A | Savoie, Brodie | Western New England |
| 3 | M | Carlson, Charles | Roanoke |
| 3 | M | Maude, Dan | Denison |
| 3 | M | Slauson, Alex | St. Lawrence |
| 3 | LSM | Morrissey, Brian | Williams |
| 3 | SP | Parah, Eric | Cortland |
| 3 | D | Love, Sam | Roanoke |
| 3 | D | Maynard, Kevin | Salisbury |
| 3 | D | Shanahan, James | Washington & Lee |
| 3 | G | Furshman, Zach | Gettysburg |
| HM | A | Beebe, Jake | Springfield |
| HM | A | Carroll, Peter | St. Lawrence |
| HM | A | Cononne, Matt | Salisbury |
| HM | A | Cosco, Nick | Endicott |
| HM | A | Costanza, Tom | Geneseo |
| HM | A | Ford, Richie | Stevenson |
| HM | A | Gibbons, Greg | Clarkson |
| HM | A | Hjelm, Max | Haverford |
| HM | A | Keigler, Will | Washington & Lee |
| HM | A | Levesque, Matt | Skidmore |
| HM | A | March, Patrick | Roanoke |
| HM | A | McNally, Clem | Tufts |
| HM | A | Oreskovich, J.R. | Stevens |
| HM | A | Reimer, Scott | Cabrini |
| HM | A | Siefert, Alec | Ithaca |
| HM | A | Tolson, Tyler | Lynchburg |
| HM | M | Alexander, Ryan | St. Mary's (MD) |
| HM | M | Bunker, Craig | Colby |
| HM | M | Campbell, Dave | Middlebury |
| HM | M | Castle, Scott | Nazareth |
| HM | M | Damm, Thayer | Washington College |
| HM | M | DeLuca, Christopher | Cortland |
| HM | M | DiPasquale, Marc | St. Mary's (MD) |
| HM | M | Furshman, Greg | Stevenson |
| HM | M | Hatton, Michael | McDaniel |
| HM | M | Heckman, Nic | Ithaca |
| HM | M | Hopkins, Skyler | Middlebury |
| HM | M | Jett, Kyle | Hampden-Sydney |
| HM | M | Kamecke, Michael Von | Salisbury |
| HM | M | Kukis, Scott | Western New England |
| HM | M | O’Reilly, Eddie | Endicott |
| HM | M | Recor, Mike | Oswego |
| HM | M | Simmons, Dolan | Eastern Connecticut |
| HM | M | Smith, Owen | Bowdoin |
| HM | M | Tuma, Justin | Roanoke |
| HM | M | Yarboro, Jordan | Tufts |
| HM | D | Deluca, John | Muhlenberg |
| HM | D | Kurpis, Tim | Gettysburg |
| HM | D | Lane, Steve | Eastern Connecticut |
| HM | D | MacRae, Daniel | RIT |
| HM | D | May, Joseph | Geneseo |
| HM | D | Mersinger, Steve | York |
| HM | D | Monroe, Joe | Cabrini |
| HM | D | Moore, Jeff | Cabrini |
| HM | D | Noble, Matt | Cortland |
| HM | D | Repko, Andrew | Bowdoin |
| HM | D | Saperstein, Eytan | Tufts |
| HM | D | Scoon, Trevor | St. Lawrence |
| HM | D | Waldie, Kirk | Wesley |
| HM | G | Bowers, Thomas | Montclair State |
| HM | G | Costanza, Dennis | Geneseo |
| HM | G | Gerbush, Michael | Williams |
| HM | G | Hagarty, Eric | Endicott |
| HM | G | Keinath, Chris | Union |
| HM | G | Locke, Connor | Washington & Lee |
| HM | G | McCleaft, James | Wesley |
Return to Main College AA Page